Skip to main content

Out of the Bottle: Ein Heldenleben Dunkelweiss and Mid-Life-Weisses

Ein Heldenleben
This post started out as an extremely belated review of my Ein Heldenleben Dunkelweiss. Then I realized that this was the perfect chance to compare it against my very similar Mid-Life-Weisses that I brewed for a friend's birthday party.

Looking at the recipes, you can see that the only major differences are that Ein Heldenleben has some Pale Wheat in it, while Mid-Life ditches the Pale Wheat for additional Dark Wheat and Munich Malt. The decoction mash, hops and yeast are the same.

Let's start with the similarities.

Mid-Lfe
Both beers have banana and clove aromas that are more muted than I had hoped for. They're backed by scents of biscuits and subtle chocolate. Although the different lighting in my pictures show otherwise, the appearance of the two beers is very close as well. Both are appropriately cloudy and have soapy heads with decent staying power. Mid-Life has maybe a touch more amber to it.

The similarities end once the beers hit the mouth.

I'll be honest and say that Ein Heldenleben is my favorite of the two. While both beers carry similar banana and clove flavors, this one has a better balanced mixture of fresh biscuits and malty sweetness. My guess is that the Pale Wheat and lower amount of Munich Malt has a lot to do with it.

Mid-Life is slightly sweeter, as would be expected with the extra Munich Malt. The wheat character is less biscuit-like too. The beer also came out with a very light astringency that I didn't expect. My friend noticed it too, so I wasn't imagining things. I'm not sure where it came from.

Overall, I'd say Ein Heldenleben is a keeper. Mid-Life, not so much. Both are nice beers to drink, but the Ein Heldenleben wins hands down.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

In the Fermentor: Bohemian Kölsch

Being a brewer on a budget, I don't have an extra fridge to lager in. That poses a bit of a problem, because I love a good Pilsener on a hot Summer day. To my palate, the closest style to Pilsener in the ale department is a German Kölsch . To that end, I've wedded a Bohemian Pilsener influenced recipe with a Kölsch yeast strain to create my Bohemian Kölsch pseudo-lager. I realize that the finished product won't be as clean, crisp and clear as a traditional Pils, but I'm hoping to come close. I want a full five gallons of this beer. Since my kitchen setup isn't conducive to five gallon all-grain batches, I've taken the partial-mash approach. I've also thrown in a bit of Irish Moss toward the end of the boil to help with clarity. Here's the five-gallon recipe: Grains: 3.5 lbs German Pilsener 8 oz Munich 8 oz Crystal 10L 4 oz CaraPils Hops: 1 oz Saaz: First Wort Hopping 0.5 oz Merkur: 60 min 1 oz Saaz: 7 min Extras: 3 lbs Pilsen ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Out of the Bottle: Insert clever use of the word Wit here

My latest Wit was a hit at my friend's birthday party. He especially liked the beer's citrus components. Others found it to be light and refreshing. I heard no Blue Moon comparisons, which actually made me quite happy. Compared to My Wit's End , this beer is much closer to style. Unmalted Wheat is part of the reason, as there's much less grainy sweetness at work. Instead, the beer is crisp and dry. The bitter orange peel really does its thing. The peel's sharp flavor melds nicely with the sweet orange peel I also used. Coriander pushes the beer's spicy character along. If I were to change anything, it would be to dial it back a notch or two. Some light sourdough aromas round out the flavor and aroma. Despite the relatively low ABV of right around 5.0%, the beer sports a fairly hefty body. Overall, I'm quite happy with this Wit. Next time, I'll hold back on the coriander. Maybe I will even take a shot at a Turbid Mash, which sounds like a great sub...
Post a Comment
Read more

Out of the Bottle: Porter vs Porter

My Beer My attempt to clone Samuel Smith Taddy Porter is ready to pour. For a change of pace, I've picked up a 4-pack of the real deal to compare and contrast against my efforts. Since I'm not exactly an impartial judge, my girlfriend agreed to blind taste test the two beers side by side in identical, unmarked glasses. I've mixed her notes in with mine. First off, I must say that the beers look remarkably similar. Taddy pours with a slightly larger head, but the beers share the same deep garnet hue. Mine has a bit more carbonation going on. Both beers have good head retention and leave some lace behind. My girlfriend's first comment was that my beer was very similar, but finished quicker than the Samuel Smith. She also noted that the Samuel Smith is slightly more bitter, with more depth of flavor. The first thing I noticed was that my beer has a more roasted edge and is a bit nuttier. It also lacks the unique dark fruit esters that I sense in all of the Samuel...
Post a Comment
Read more